How To Choose a Suitable Granulator
How To Choose a Suitable Granulator? Vacuum vs. Non-Vacuum Granulator
In-Depth Review of Precious Metal Granulators: Vacuum or Non-Vacuum? Don’t Let “Over-Specification” Drain Your Profits!
In the precious metal processing industry, granulation is the critical bottleneck process connecting “raw materials” and “finished products”. Whether you are engaged in gold bar stamping, jewelry casting, or precious metal recycling, choosing the right granulator is paramount.
Many investors or factory owners often feel confused when purchasing granulators: “Vacuum granulators are much more expensive, are they really necessary?” “Non-vacuum granulators offer better value for money, but will they affect the quality of gold bars?”
A significant misconception exists in the market: “The more expensive the equipment, the better; vacuum is always better than non-vacuum.”
Is this really true? Research based on thousands of factories reveals that many investors spend heavily on vacuum granulators only to find later that production efficiency has decreased and maintenance costs have doubled. In fact, vacuum granulators are primarily designed for handling “alloy-type” metals. For most high-purity gold and silver, non-vacuum equipment is more than sufficient.
Today, we break down the underlying logic to help you calculate the true cost and choose the right “profit-making machine”.
I. Core Logic: Why is “Vacuum” Not Necessary for Everyone?
To make the correct choice, you must first understand what problem a vacuum environment actually solves.
1. Vacuum Granulator: The “Lifesaver” for Alloys
The core of vacuum granulation lies in “absolute oxygen isolation”.
When you are processing K-gold, rose gold, hard gold alloys, or precious metal alloys containing active metals (such as zinc, nickel, copper), vacuum is essential.
*The Pain Point: Non-gold components in alloys oxidize easily at high temperatures, generating dross, leading to particle segregation and dull/discolored appearance.
*The Value of Vacuum: Melting in a vacuum environment effectively prevents the burning loss of alloying elements, ensures precise composition ratios, and guarantees particles are free from internal oxide inclusions.
2. Non-Vacuum Granulator: The “King of Cost-Effectivity” for Pure Gold and Silver
For Au99.99 (high-purity gold) or Ag99.99 (sterling silver), the situation is completely different.
*Physical Properties: High-purity gold and silver themselves possess strong chemical stability and do not readily react violently with oxygen at their melting points.
*Protective Atmosphere: Modern non-vacuum granulators are not “operating naked in air.” They utilize a sealed furnace chamber + graphite crucible + inert gas (Argon/Nitrogen) protection.
Conclusion: As long as the protective gas is properly applied, the granules produced from pure gold and silver will be equally bright and lustrous, fully meeting the standards for subsequent rolling and trading.
II. Three-Dimensional Comparison: How Costly is Choosing the Wrong Equipment?
1. Production Efficiency: Time is Money
• Vacuum Equipment: Each batch requires the cycle of “pumping vacuum → filling gas → melting → cooling → breaking vacuum.” A single cycle often takes 40-60 minutes. For gold refineries pursuing high output, this is like putting shackles on the production line.
• Non-Vacuum Equipment: Employing continuous or quasi-continuous melting modes, eliminating the need for repeated vacuum pumping. Their capacity is typically 1.5 to 2 times that of a vacuum unit with the same power rating.
2. Operating Costs: The Invisible “Electricity Bills & Consumables”
• Vacuum Equipment: Vacuum pumps require continuous operation, sealing rings are high-frequency wear parts, and any air leak can scrap an entire batch. Maintaining a technician skilled in vacuum systems also adds to labor costs.
• Non-Vacuum Equipment: Simple and robust structure. The main consumable is the graphite crucible. Maintenance can be handled by a regular electrician. Overall operating costs are 30%-50% lower than vacuum equipment.
3. Equipment Price: The Pressure of Initial Investment
A vacuum granulator of the same capacity typically costs 2-3 times more than a non-vacuum unit.
• If you are in the business of high-purity gold trading, spending an extra hundred thousand or even several hundred thousand dollars does not bring additional product premium.
• If you are engaged in precision alloy development, this investment is an essential entry fee.
III. Deep Analysis: Which Type of Customer Are You?
To guide you towards a “no-regret” choice, please refer to the following three typical scenarios:
Scenario A: Gold Recyclers & Gold Bar Producers
Main Business: Purifying scrap, gold ingots and then granulating them to prepare for making 1g-100g investment gold bars.
Expert Advice: Firmly choose a [Non-Vacuum Granulator].
Reason: Requirements for internal porosity in pure gold granules can be addressed through “pressure casting” or “graphite mold design.” The high output rate of non-vacuum equipment helps you quickly recoup funds and reduce the processing cost per gram of gold.
Scenario B: K-Gold Jewelry Supporting Factories
Main Business: Producing 14K, 18K gold beans (granules) for downstream jewelry factories to use in casting.
Expert Advice: Must choose a [Vacuum Granulator].
Reason: The master alloy (“bukuo”) in K-gold is highly prone to oxidation. A non-vacuum environment leads to a thick layer of oxide scale on the granule surface, resulting in jewelry castings with numerous pinholes and an extremely high rejection rate.
Scenario C: Silver Trading & Industrial Silver Use
Main Business: Producing large batches of silver granules (around 15kg).
Expert Advice: Choose a [Non-Vacuum / Protective Atmosphere Granulator].
Reason: Silver has a lower unit price, and the goal is economies of scale. Non-vacuum equipment paired with large-capacity furnace chambers is the only efficient solution for achieving industrialized mass production.
IV. Pitfall Avoidance Guide: 3 Golden Standards When Buying a Granulator
Regardless of the final process you choose, focus on these three points:
1. Sealing of the Graphite Crucible: For a good non-vacuum machine, there should be high-quality sealing between the furnace lid and body to ensure nitrogen can form an effective “positive pressure protection.”
2. Mixing Uniformity: Especially when working with alloys, does it have magnetic stirring or mechanical stirring? This impacts the uniformity of granule composition more than the presence of a vacuum environment.
3. Cooling Water Circulation System: The essence of granulation is “rapid cooling and solidification.” If the cooling speed is insufficient, even in a vacuum, the produced granules will be misshapen and dull.
# The Ultimate Algorithm for Return on Investment (ROI)
To help clarify your thinking, we have compiled the following table:
V. Conclusion: Choose the Right One, Not the Expensive One
For investors in the gold processing field, the most taboo is “technical overkill.”
▶ Vacuum Granulators are the “precision weapons” for alloy processing—accurate, high-end, but delicate and slow.
▶ Non-Vacuum Granulators are the “heavy-duty tanks” for high-purity gold and silver—durable, highly efficient, and extremely cost-effective.
“Vacuum for alloys, non-vacuum for pure gold/silver”—this is not just a technical conclusion, but a “golden rule for profitability” honed by industry veterans.
Are you still hesitating about the configuration?
| Dimension | Non-Vacuum Granulator | Vacuum Granulator |
| Initial Investment | Lower (suitable for startups and medium-scale operations) | Higher (suitable for high-end positioning and large-scale factories) |
| Product Appearance | Good (metallic luster, slight color variation) | Excellent (full bright surface, no oxidation layer) |
| Particle Density | Standard | Extremely high (no internal porosity) |
| Maintenance Difficulty | Simple, can be maintained by general electricians | Requires professional periodic maintenance of vacuum pumps and seals |
| Recommended Scenario | Industrial gold bar materials, bulk silver ingot granulation | Investment gold beans, precision jewelry materials, special alloys |
We have prepared a “Granulation Equipment ROI Comparison Table” for you, including data on electricity consumption, wear parts lists, and daily production capacity under different specifications.
# We Can Provide For You:
1. On-site Material Testing: Bring your own materials and compare the actual output quality between vacuum and non-vacuum processes.
2. Production Line Configuration Planning: From melting to granulation, to back-end rolling and stamping, we provide one-stop efficiency optimization solutions.
3. Instead of Paying for “Overhyped” Specs, Invest in “Tangible” Profits.
Based on our experience serving thousands of gold and silver processing enterprises, we recommend:
1. Beginners / Focusing on Bulk Gold & Silver Recycling: Recommend a Medium-Frequency Non-Vacuum Granulator. Utilize the lower procurement cost to quickly establish cash flow. By increasing protective gas flow, you can also produce granules with high market acceptance.
2. High-end Brands / Precision Processing Factories: Must be equipped with a Vacuum Granulator. In the globalized gold market, the microscopic density and macroscopic color of granules directly represent a company’s technical threshold. Vacuum equipment can save you significant subsequent labor costs for acid washing and polishing.
Click [Consult Us] below or call [86-15168765707] to have our senior engineers provide a one-on-one equipment selection plan for you！！！